Pros and Cons of Mulching vs. Bagging Grass When You Mow

2024-06-27
Pros and Cons of Mulching vs. Bagging Grass When You Mow

Lawn aficionados—those who love to mow—tend to have strong opinions on whether it is best to mulch lawn clippings or bag them. While the mulching vs. bagging debate is dependent on several factors, there is one firm conclusion about lawn clippings that all turf scientists agree on: Clippings are rich in nutrients and should be recycled back into the landscape.

The science-based pros and cons presented here can help you decide whether to recycle clippings with a mulching mower or a bagging attachment. Use these pros and cons to choose the best tactic for your patch of grass.

Pros of Mulching Lawn Clippings

Mulching—when we’re talking about mowing—refers to returning lawn clippings to the turf. All lawnmowers can mulch clippings. Some mowers are designed to finely chop the clippings. These mowers are usually sold as mulching mowers, and they have an advantage over standard rotary mowers thanks to the ease of distributing the finely chopped clippings. The advantage is slight; in typical mowing conditions, a rotary mower and a mulching mower perform equally well.

Homeowners who mulch their lawn clippings benefit their grass in several ways.

Return Nutrients to the Turf

Clippings are rich in nitrogen and other valuable nutrients. As the clippings break down, the nutrients are released into the soil, where they are captured by plant roots. Returning clippings to the turf over a single season provides about 25 percent of the nitrogen a grass plant needs to grow well. This is equivalent to at least one fertilizer application per year.

Improve Soil Texture

As grass clippings decompose into the lawn, microbial activity improves the soil texture. New water and nutrient channels form, improving clay and sandy soils with the addition of organic matter. Over time, the soil improved by decomposing lawn clippings is more absorbent and well-drained.

Increase Carbon Sequestration

Lawns capture carbon. By returning carbon-laden clippings to the turf, the carbon is quickly reabsorbed and sequestered, reducing the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Turf scientists have found that recycling clippings into the lawn increased the net carbon sequestration of a lawn by 11 to 59 percent over removing clippings.

Save Time and Labor

Mulching clippings is easy! The lawn mower does all the work. There is no need to heave bagged clippings into a compost bin or scatter them over open soil. Mulching clippings eliminates the need to find a municipal disposal method if composting isn’t an option.

Cons of Mulching Lawn Clippings

Excessively long clippings can pile up on the lawn, shading the grass that is trying to grow beneath. In extreme cases, the piles of clippings can smother turf. A rule of thumb is that clippings 1 inch in length can be safely returned to the lawn. Clippings longer than an inch should be collected and added to the compost pile or used as mulch in the landscape.

Myth: Clippings Cause Thatch

Clippings have a bad reputation for piling up between the soil surface and the actively growing grass plants to create a layer of thatch. Turf scientists have found that clippings decompose so quickly they don’t have a chance to accumulate. Clippings break down rapidly, sending the valuable nutrients they contain into the soil.

Many homeowners have heard that mulching clippings contributes to thatch buildup in a lawn, but that concern is overstated. Thatch can be caused by too much nitrogen fertilizer and infrequent mowing. It is also more common on compacted soils and with some grass varieties.

Bottom line: Clippings don’t cause thatch.

Pros of Bagging Clippings

There are real benefits to bagging clippings. When cutting long grass, bagging clippings prevents them from smothering the turf. Bagged grass clippings are useful as mulch in the landscape; spread a 2-inch-thick layer of clippings over soil to prevent weeds. Bagged clippings are also useful in a compost pile where they decompose along with brown matter, such as dried leaves, to make humus that will enrich the soil. Bagging clippings prevents them from littering walkways and clogging drains. Smart mowing tactics can eliminate clipping litter, too.

Cons of Bagging Clippings

Bagging clippings removes a valuable source of nitrogen from the lawn. Twenty-five percent of turf’s nitrogen needs can be met through mulching clippings back into the lawn. Bagging clippings becomes costly when you factor in the fertilizer needed to offset the lost nitrogen.

Bagging clippings is more time-consuming and labor-intensive than mulching. A full bag of clippings, especially wet clippings, is heavy; disposing of clippings in a compost pile requires strength. If you don’t have a compost area or use for the clippings in the landscape, you’re faced with the challenge of finding a way to dispose of them. Some municipalities accept yard waste; others do not.  

Final Word: Mulching vs. Bagging

When possible, mulch clippings back into the lawn. The soil benefits of mulching and the nutrient boost provided by the clippings make this option the winner in almost all circumstances. From a practical time and labor standpoint, mulching clippings is easier and faster. The mower does the work, and your lawn reaps the benefits.

Related Article

How to Plant and Grow Rose of Jericho

How to Plant and Grow Rose of Jericho

Rose of Jericho is a unique houseplant that can survive with minimal water, making it a great option for travelers and forgetful gardeners.
21 Adorably Petite Plants for Fairy Gardens

21 Adorably Petite Plants for Fairy Gardens

Color is always nice, but scale is everything when choosing miniature garden plants. Peruse our favorite picks for fairy gardens and terrariums.
13 Colorful Nectar Plants for Pollinators

13 Colorful Nectar Plants for Pollinators

Create a gorgeous, pollinator-friendly garden by including these nectar-rich plants.
Is Coleus a Perennial or Annual? Here's How to Grow It Both Ways

Is Coleus a Perennial or Annual? Here's How to Grow It Both Ways

Is coleus a perennial that comes back every year? That depends on where you live and how you care for it. Use these tips to enjoy coleus as a colorful perennial or annual plant.
How to Plant and Grow Ranunculus

How to Plant and Grow Ranunculus

Ranunculus are favorite flowers for weddings, arrangements, and gardens. Here's how to plant and grow ranunculus.
How to Plant and Grow Glossy Abelia

How to Plant and Grow Glossy Abelia

This guide on how to grow glossy abelia includes essential planting and care tips such watering, fertilizing, and pruning needs. You'll also find popular types of abelia to grow and pretty companion plants for this flowering shrub.
Hydrangeas Not Blooming? 7 Reasons Why and How to Fix the Problem

Hydrangeas Not Blooming? 7 Reasons Why and How to Fix the Problem

Hydrangeas not blooming can be a frustrating problem for gardeners. These straightforward tips will promote tons of long-lasting flowers.
10 Best Sweet Potato Companion Plants for Larger Harvests

10 Best Sweet Potato Companion Plants for Larger Harvests

Mix and match these sweet potato companion plants in your vegetable beds for pest-free crops and easier gardening.
How to Harvest Mint, Dry Mint, and Store Mint

How to Harvest Mint, Dry Mint, and Store Mint

Learn how to harvest mint to keep plants more manageable and gather fresh mint leaves for cooking, drying, and storing!
How and When to Harvest Radishes at Their Peak

How and When to Harvest Radishes at Their Peak

These easy-to-follow tips will help you figure out how and when to harvest radishes for the best flavor and size. Plus, get troubleshooting advice if your radish roots aren't developing properly.
How and When to Start Tomato Seeds Indoors

How and When to Start Tomato Seeds Indoors

Find out exactly how and when to start tomato seeds indoors so they'll be ready to transplant into your garden in spring.
Tillers vs. Cultivators: How to Choose the Right One for Your Gardening Tasks

Tillers vs. Cultivators: How to Choose the Right One for Your Gardening Tasks

Learn the differences between tillers and cultivators and the tasks they're best suited for.
Here’s What Not to Put in Compost to Avoid a Contaminated Bin

Here’s What Not to Put in Compost to Avoid a Contaminated Bin

Composting is a simple way to turn your kitchen and yard waste into food for your garden. But some of these items should never be in compost.
Easy Lawn Repair for Patchy Grass Using Seed or Sod

Easy Lawn Repair for Patchy Grass Using Seed or Sod

With a bit of grass seed or sod, lawn repair is easy, and you’ll soon have a lush green carpet again.
What Are the Tiny White Bugs on Your Plants? 4 Common Pests They Could Be

What Are the Tiny White Bugs on Your Plants? 4 Common Pests They Could Be

Tiny white bugs on plants in your home or outdoors can be a big problem. Learn how to identify and get rid of them with this guide.
How to Spot 5 Common Plant Diseases and Keep Your Garden Healthy

How to Spot 5 Common Plant Diseases and Keep Your Garden Healthy

Protect your plants from the most common diseases. Learn to recognize the symptoms and how to prevent these diseases in the first place.
How to Landscape with Rocks and Stones in Your Yard

How to Landscape with Rocks and Stones in Your Yard

Decorative rocks and stones add another element of nature to your yard, whether you grow hydrangeas, tulips, or cacti.
Landscape Planning Tips From Start to Finish for a Perfect Yard

Landscape Planning Tips From Start to Finish for a Perfect Yard

Even if you're a beginner, these simple landscape planning tips will take the mystery out of designing your yard's ideal layout.
10 Native Alternatives to Invasive Plants Growing in Your Garden

10 Native Alternatives to Invasive Plants Growing in Your Garden

Use native plants in your garden instead of popular invasive landscape plants: See a list of common invasive plants, plus native alternatives to plant instead.
Your Seasonal Lawn-Care Schedule for the Midwest

Your Seasonal Lawn-Care Schedule for the Midwest

Use our lawn-care schedule to help you maintain a beautiful yard all year long. You'll learn exactly when to mow, aerate, fertilize, and overseed.